Skip to main content

Tun M: Weapon of the Weak or Strong?

Citizens of any dispossessed and disenfranchised nation, according to James Scott, often have to resort to "weapons of the weak" to get their voices heard.

Scott, who is an eminent political scientist at the Center of Agrarian Studies at Yale University may well be right.

When robbed of any meaningful chance of change, such as the right to a free and fair election, they may resort to various means to get their voices heard.

Of course, terrorism is often considered the "ultimate," weapon of the weak. This ‘weapon’ should be condemned without fail.

But when Malaysians turn to a former Prime Minister like Tun Dr Mahathir, invariably, to set the previous course straight, one wonders why such a choice needs to be lashed time and again ?

Even the campaign of "Undi Rosak," appears to come on the heels of Pakatan Harapan's decision to turn Tun Dr Mahathir as its leader.

Thus, why does one need to vent such spleen against one man, when the likes of Anwar Ibrahim, Mohamad Sabu, Lim Kit Siang and Lim Guan Eng, all of whom had been unfairly imprisoned by the state before, had unanimously agreed to let put aside their own personal sufferings for the sake of the Nation and its salvation?

In other words, why should their "transactional forgiveness," not be accepted and examplified by all? Everyone should, especially if it is all agreed that the redemption of Malaysia lies in Tun Dr Mahathir redeeming himself first. After all, the current system of corruption did originate from the 1980s, when Tun Dr Mahathir was at the helm. If Tun Dr Mahathir wants to set Malaysia free, shouldn't he be given the chance, perhaps a final one?

Of course, the likes of P Gunasegaran, an avid writer at BizKini, is right to raise the spectre of Tun Dr Mahathir becoming a lapsed alcoholic again; one who will be immediately drunk with power when given a liquored drink.

But in all fairness to Gunasegaran, due diligence should be given to the timing and the operating system of the choice too.

To begin with, Pakatan Harapan has come of age. It is not as ‘naive’ as before. Compared to 1998, or, 2008, the opposition is now more, not less, prepared. This is true from the ground up, as it is from the top down.

If anything, the offer of a prospective premiership, and leadership, was not given to Tun Dr Mahathir on a silver platter. To form a new government, Tun Dr Mahathir is now learning the ropes of politics anew. Not bad for a 92 year old man.

At various meetings and sessions, everyone has had their chance to say their piece, without fail. And, Tun Dr Mahathir has listened intently.

In other words, there is no hegemon in Pakatan Harapan, only a decision making process led by consensus. While this may occasionally be unwieldy, it works.

If anything, Pakatan Harapan, is replete with an immense spirit of give and take, one which seeks to typify the true or average Malaysian at work.

Secondly, while Bersatu led by Tun Dr Mahathir may have the chance to compete in 52 parliamentary seats in Semenanjung, PKR is close behind with 51, while DAP and Amanah have 35 and 27 seats respectively.

Tun Dr Mahathir, for the lack of better word, cannot "game" or engineer the coalition to work in his favor alone. To be in power, he needs the consent of other partners, whose representation are almost proportionate to one another. To implement a policy and mke a decision, when in power, he needs the agreement of the others. This is not BN but PH, a completely different breed of personalities.

Thirdly, with Sarawak and Sabah contributing another 56 seats to the parliament, Tun Dr Mahathir would be literally walking into a loaded political landmine that is the Federation. He cannot do as he pleases anymore.

Thus, he cannot unilaterally attempt any Federal endeavor without the consent of these two states, especially when the local sentiments have captured both the imagination and self belief of the (Malaysian) natives in Borneo.

Finally, while politics may not necessarily reflect anything divine (where forgiveness is vital), the spirit of live-and-let live must, as a rule, become the crucible of any multi ethnic political system too; precisely because anything less would be destructive to the entire edifice.

It is in this vein that Amanah, by extension, Pakatan Harapan, considers it crucial to have the leadership of Tun Dr Mahathir at the fore.

He may not have been the first to light the torch of reforms. But at the very least he is operating in a system of coalition where he can no longer blow out the flame.

This, in a nutshell, is how Malaysia should work. And, it is also a reflection of the weapons of the strong, with Tun Dr Mahathir enabling Pakatan Harapan, and Pakatan Harapan in turn empowering him. And again, to a limit. And it is the strong, which is PH, for only the strong can garner and harness such potential and under such circumstances.

WaLlahu 'Alam
KHALID ABD SAMAD

Comments

BE PART OF SOLUTION NOT PROBLEM.
SOMETIMES YOU ARE RIGHT BUT NOT ALL THE TIME OTHERS ARE WRONG.

Popular posts from this blog

Surat Terbuka Untuk Penduduk Seksyen 23

2hb September 2009 M 13 Ramadan 1430 H السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته Kehadapan penduduk Seksyen 23 yang dihormati, Semoga surat ini menemui tuan-tuan dalam keadaan sihat wal afiat serta keimanan yang teguh dan jitu berkat bulan Ramadhan ini. Saya mengambil kesempatan ini untuk mengingatkan diri saya serta tuan-tuan akan Firman Allah, Surah Al Maaidah ayat 8 yang bermaksud; “Bertindak adil! Ianya lebih rapat dengan keTaqwaan.” Semoga dalam usaha kita membina keTaqwaan dalam bulan Ramadhan ini, kita mengingati hakikat bahawa ‘keTaqwaan’ yang diusahakan itu mempunyai hubungan rapat dengan keadilan. Keadilan ini pula perlu dilaksanakan terhadap semua, walaupun terhadap yang tidak disenangi. Ini ditegaskan di dalam ayat yang sama yang bermaksud, “dan jangan oleh kerana kebencian kamu terhadap sesuatu kaum menyebabkan kamu tidak berlaku adil…” Kalau terhadap kaum yang dibenci sekalipun dituntut keadilan, apatah lagi terhadap jiran sekampung dan warga sekota? Walaupun mereka tidak seba

Keadilan Saidina Umar Al-Khattab Terhadap Rumah Ibadah Agama Lain

Saya ingin mengambil kesempatan ini untuk mengemukakan sebuah kisah dari zaman pemerintahan Saidina Umar Al-Khattab (r.a) untuk tatapan dan renungan tuan-tuan sekalian. Melalui pendedahan ini, adalah diharap sebahagian dari ummat Islam yang tidak memahami konsep keadilan Islam terhadap agama lain, akan sedikit sebanyak dapat memikirkan kembali sikap dan pendirian mereka itu. Kisah yang ingin dikemukakan adalah kisah Saidina Umar dan Kanisah (gereja) Al-Qiamah yang terletak di Quds. Kisah ini adalah petikan dari muka surat 114, kitab Itmam al-Wafa’ fi sirah al-Khulafa’ , tulisan as-Syeikh Muhammad bin al-Afifi al-Banjuri, Darul Ibnu Hazim. “Dan apabila masuknya Saidina Umar ke dalam kota, maka masuklah beliau ke dalam Kanisah (gereja) al-Qiamah, dan beliau duduk di ruang utama gereja tersebut . Setelah tiba waktu solat asar, maka berkata Saidina Umar kepada Patriach Kanisah tersebut, “Saya ingin mengerjakan solat.” Jawab Patriach: “Solat sahajalah di sini”. Tetapi Umar menolak cadan

Tapak Kuil Seksyen 23 Shah Alam

Baru-baru ini, banyak betul yang kita dengar berhubung isu tapak kuil yang dicadangkan di Seksyen 23, Shah Alam. Yang tahu, yang tak tahu dan yang buat-buat tahu, semuanya turut sama mengemukakan pandangan masing-masing. Di antaranya, pandangan Noh Omar yang menyatakan bagaimana kerajaan PR tidak peka terhadap sensitiviti umat Islam. Oleh itu, bagi mereka yang ingin tahu, izinkan saya menceritakan serba sedikit perkara sebenar berkenaan isu ini. Tapak Kuil yang dicadangkan adalah di kawasan Industri, lebih 200 meter dari kawasan perumahan. Sebuah Kuil yang sekarang ini berada di Seksyen 19 akan dipindahkan ke tapak baru yang dicadangkan ini. Di Seksyen 19, kuil berkenaan hanya berjarak 20 kaki dari kawasan perumahan! Buka pintu rumah, seberang jalan terdapat kuil. Sebenarnya, kuil Seksyen 19 telah berada di situ sejak zaman sebelum wujudnya Shah Alam lagi. Pada masa itu kawasan di mana kuil tersebut dibina dinamakan Ladang Sungai Renggam. Apabila PKNS ambil-alih, maka dijadikan kaw