Skip to main content

PH, Zaid and the Oysters Diner

This is my response in full to Malaysiakini journalist, Alyaa with regards to PH, Zaid and his oysters dinner.

I respect his opinion but I think that Dato Zaid is jumping the gun so to say. It is a little extreme to draw conclusions from the Sarawak state elections that a coalition between PKR, DAP and AMANAH, ie Pakatan Harapan is no longer worth the effort. We must understand the circumstances and conditions behind its formation and the intricacies involved. Suffice to say that PH is less than a year old and faced opposition to its formation even within the leadership of the opposition and the civil society. Nonetheless it came into being and took to the Sarawak polls as best it could, given the circumstances.

So although contests amongst the coalition partners are a disappointment, it must be said that it is only in less than 10% of the seats contested.

Secondly it must be said that Sarawak is unique and both PKR and DAP have equally strong claims on a few seats. This has been acknowledged all along so much so that when we wanted to form PH, there were a few who suggested we wait until after the Sarawak state elections predicting, correctly, that there would be contests between PH members during the elections given the circumstances. However we went ahead because we believed it could be managed and even if it did happen, it would be limited and would not spell the end of PH.

Last but not least… Is fact that even with Pakatan Rakyat, which was formed in 2008, inter party contests still occurred in 2013! Although enraging, in particular the ones involving PAS in Semenanjung, it did not prevent the formation of PR governments in Selangor and Penang, two states where the inter party contests occurred. Therefore, although it is a shortcoming and a fault, it is by no way necessarily fatal. Unless of course if one wants to use it as an excuse to kill the coalition.

I am not insinuating Zaid is trying to use this as an excuse to kill the coalition, but I am suggesting that it takes more than that to necessitate a divorce. The coalition is a must as all 3 parties have their strengths and area of influence. We just have to improve a little bit more and work harder in order to be ready for the 14th GE.

WaLlahu 'Alam
KHALID SAMAD

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Berakhirnya Drama RUU 355?

Drama perlaksanaan sistem perundangan Islam yang mengambil bentuk usul persendirian YB Marang berhubung Akta 355 kelihatan menghampiri adegan penamatnya. Pada peringkat kesudahannya UMNO/BN kelihatan sebagai pihak yang meraih keuntungan terbesar dengan pembangkang berada dalam keadaan berpecah dan tidak bersepakat. Keutuhan Pakatan Rakyat yang telah mewarnai pilihan raya ke 13 pada 2013 sudah jelas hilang. Yang sepatutnya mengambil tempatnya, iaitu Pakatan Harapan, masih dalam keadaan sedikit terumbang-ambing, khususnya berhubung hubungan dengan PAS.

Tindakan UMNO/BN untuk mensasarkan PAS melalui isu perundangan Islam adalah satu ‘master-stroke’ yang tidak boleh dinafikan mana-mana pihak. Melaluinya bukan sahaja PR berpecah, namun ketidak-tentuan sikap terhadap PAS menyebabkan apa-apa tindakbalas untuk menyelamatkan keadaan menjadi tidak padu dan kurang bersungguh-sungguh. Kebergantungan terhadap PAS oleh pihak tertentu menyebabkan mereka tidak sanggup memutuskan hubungan dengan PAS s…

Kenyataan Media Amanah Mengenai RUU 355

Muqaddimah

Amanah menganggap mahkamah syariah sebagai institusi penting dalam usaha menzahirkan kebenaran dan keadilan Islam. Oleh itu imejnya sebagai institusi yang cekap dan berwibawa perlu sentiasa dijaga. Amanah bersetuju bahawa segala usaha ke arah memperkasakan mahkamah syariah, dari segi kecekapan perlaksanaan undang-undang Islam, perlu disokong dan dibantu.

Kenyataan Berhubung Usul Persendirian Marang: Cadangan Pindaan ke Atas Akta 355

MUQADDIMAH

1. AMANAH ingin menegaskan bahawa Mahkamah Syariah adalah institusi keadilan Islam dan oleh itu apa jua usaha ke arah menperkasakannya adalah disokong. Bidang kuasanya berhubung kesalahan jenayah syariah dijelaskan dalam Akta 355 sediada. Akta 355 ini perlu dijaga dengan baik dan apa jua usaha pembaik-pulihan serta pindaan terhadapnya perlu diperhalusi secara teliti supaya tidak menjejas kedudukan mahkamah syariah.

2. Akta 355 sediada telah digubal mengambil kira kedudukan dan peranan Mahkamah Syariah di dalam kerangka struktur kenegaraan Malaysia yang di dalamnya wujud Mahkamah Sivil dan juga Mahkamah Syariah. Sepertimana diketahui umum, bidang kuasa Mahkamah Syariah adalah terhad kepada orang Islam dan kesalahan-kesalahan tertentu seperti terkandung dalam Senarai II Senarai Negeri Jadual kesembilan Perlembagaan Persekutuan. Selainnya adalah di bawah Mahkamah Sivil.

3. Apa jua pindaan yang ingin dibawa semestinya selari dengan kedudukan dan peranan ini supaya tidak berlaku…